Jim Douglas for Governor
June 24, 2008
http://www.JimDouglas.org
Ten Ways Speaker Symington Sends
Shivers Through Vermont’s Business Community
1. Icy Roads Ahead: Symington’s Gas Tax
With $4 per gallon for gasoline and nearly $5 per gallon for diesel, businesses are struggling to fill their tanks. If Symington had her way, folks would be paying more at the pump today.
In 2006 Symington stated that adding 4 cents to the gasoline tax and 6 cents to the diesel tax "makes sense." (Burlington Free Press, 3/17/06) She remained steadfast in her support of the gas tax increase despite understanding, "We recognize that the gas tax is politically difficult when the price of gas is so high…" (Burlington Free Press, 4/29/06)
In 2007 Symington again considered a gasoline tax increase. "Symington and other Democrats say increasing the gas tax is just one of the options that should be considered." (WCAX, 8/14/07)
2. Not Too Cold for Flip-Flips: Symington’s Property Tax Reform Reversal
As Vermonters struggle with greater anxiety about the national economy, Symington wanted to backtrack on common sense reform to curb out-of-control property taxes. After initially supporting a breakthrough two-vote law for school budgets, Symington caved to special influence and flip-flopped the very next session – before the new law had even been tested!
First, the Flip: When it was initially passed, "House Speaker Gaye Symington, D-Jericho, praised the new law for accomplishing cost containment while maintaining equal access to funding for children throughout the state. She said, too, that the law respects voters’ role in making budget decisions by providing them with information to help them make choices rather than using penalties to force certain outcomes." (Burlington Free Press, Education law praised, 6/12/07).
Then, the Flop: After special interest pressure, Symington questions Vermonters’ intelligence by suggesting that they are incapable of understanding the law: "‘Confusion is not cost containment. It is fine if Vermonters choose to vote down a school budget based on good information. But if they turn down a school budget due to confusion, Vermont schoolchildren lose out,’ said Speaker of the House Gaye Symington, D-Jericho, in a statement." (Rutland Herald, 2/29/08).
3. Out in the cold: Symington Opposed Common Sense Housing Bill
Symington’s track record of out-of-the-mainstream views is clearly shown through her opposition to the Governor’s New Neighborhood initiative. Local business leaders pleaded with the Symington: "‘It’s getting harder to attract employees and harder to keep them,’ Central Vermont Chamber of Commerce Executive Director George Malek said. ‘…There needs to be a greater incentive to build housing and preferably, to build it near the existing commercial centers.’" Malek continues saying that Symington never even gave the proposal a real chance: "‘The bill in the House –Speaker Gaye Symington – she just shot up one side of it and down the other, which is largely a reflection of what happened in the Natural Resources committee.’" (Times Argus, 4/17/07).
4. Business Leaders Not Getting that Warm Fuzzy Feeling from Democrat Leadership
Over the last two years, Symington and Senate President Pro Tem Peter Shumlin have made going after Vermont Yankee a full-time job. This past session, as Symington and Shumlin were hatching yet another scheme that could have raised electric rates on families and employers, the business community stepped in to respectfully voice their concerns. The press conference got heated when Sen. Shumlin interrupted and called a highly respected, high ranking official from IBM a liar. The exchange went like this:
"[IBM Government Affairs Manager, John] O'Kane: ‘Money has time value, and you're changing the time.’
Shumlin: ‘We are not asking for the money. You're lying about that. We are not asking for the money. The bill says...’
O'Kane: ‘Peter, that is. You just called me a liar.’
Shumlin: ‘I said you're not telling the truth about that, John.’
O'Kane: ‘You called me a liar. That is unacceptable. You're the president of the Senate, and you're calling me, a representative of the largest employer...’" (Burlington Free Press, VT BUZZ – 4/22/08)
Talk about throwing cold water in someone’s face! Governor Douglas was quick to issue a statement to IBM apologizing for Sen. Shumlin’s inappropriate behavior. Speaker Symington remained silent on the matter.
5. Paycheck Shrinkage: Payroll & Income Taxes
In 2005, Symington wanted to take a chunk out of Vermonters’ paychecks to pay for her health care plan. She was open to raising taxes to pay for a single payer government run health care plan. "Her goal is for the Health Care Committee to spend the summer and fall exploring the taxes that would be needed to pay for its system, which the panel presumes would be payroll or income taxes or a combination of them, and to figure out who would be covered and what that coverage would be." (Brattleboro Reformer, 4/4/05)
Later that year, the Legislature under Gaye Symington’s leadership proposed raising taxes for a government run health care plan. "The Legislature proposed a 3 percent payroll tax paid by companies that didn't offer coverage to their employees and a 1 percent income tax on those receiving the proposed primary care benefit." (Brattleboro Reformer, 8/19/05)
6. Warning: Frost Heave Ahead: Symington Opposes Circ Highway and Bennington Bypass
Despite calls from business leaders in Bennington and Chittenden County, Symington remains opposed to important construction projects that will ease traffic congestion and spur economic growth in those areas.
"The speaker remains opposed to large projects like the Circumferential Highway in Chittenden County and the Bennington Bypass…" (Eagle Times, 9/14/07)
7. Frozen Solid on Sales Tax Holiday
As Vermonters struggle with greater anxiety about the national economy, Symington resisted measures to give Vermonters and local merchants a holiday from the state sales tax.
Vermont merchant David Perry said, "‘We've had dozens of people in already, looking at appliances and telling us they're waiting for that weekend,’ he said. Bradford is just across the Connecticut River from sales-tax-free New Hampshire, and Perry said Vermont's sales tax had been troublesome to him for a long time."
Symington doesn’t see it that way. "‘I don't think it is the best use of taxpayer resources,’ she said… ‘I don't think it benefits the Vermonters who are struggling to make ends meet.’" (Burlington Free Press, 5/2/08)
8. Businesses are Snowed In: Symington Opposes Permit Reform
Symington was once again at odds with business leaders and employers with her out-of-the-mainstream opposition to bipartisan and much needed permit reform measures.
"Several business groups, including the Vermont Ski Areas Association, the Lake Champlain Regional Chamber of Commerce and Greater Burlington Industrial Corp., backed the Douglas plan Thursday, describing it as a way to expedite what has become at times a complicated and lengthy process that has hurt economic development.
‘What we’ve wanted all along is a more timely, predictable permitting process. This will do both,’ said Sheri Larson, director of government relations for the Lake Champlain Chamber and GBIC." (Rutland Herald, 2/7/03)
Symington Voted against permit reform twice. When, in 2003, H.175 passed the house by a vote 78 to 53 on April 11, 2003, Symington voted against the bill. In 2004, Symington once again voted against permit reform when the house voted overwhelmingly to support the final bill, which passed the house 114-24.
9. Winter Storm Warning in Effect for Trucks and Family Vehicles
Even when members of the business community explain that the gas guzzler tax would harm Vermont businesses, Symington sticks to her government-knows-best philosophy suggesting that Vermonters must be taxed into making good choices for their businesses and their families.
"We [NFIB] opposed the gas guzzler charges because of the negative impact it would have had on our members who rely heavily on trucks and vans to operate their businesses." (NFIB/Vermont State House News, 4/20/007)
"Despite some vehement opposition to pending legislation in the House that would assess a $150 tariff on new vehicles that get poor gas mileage, Symington said improving the environment isn't at odds with individuals' financial well-being.
‘We're trying to help people move away from vehicles that are incredibly inefficient … and provide incentives and nudges to move Vermonters to make good choices…’" (Rutland Herald, 4/11/07)
10. Symington’s Ski Patrol: Husband Lacy to the Rescue
When business leaders got involved in 2006 legislative races, they supported both Democrats and Republicans much like other interest groups. Symington’s husband, Chuck Lacy was angered by their involvement and decided to take action.
"Chuck Lacy, a prominent Vermont businessman who is also the husband of the Democratic speaker of the Vermont House, is waging a campaign against businesses who are waging a campaign against his wife's party.
…But Lacy's impromptu telephone blitz to many of the state's car dealers and other businesses has rankled members of the coalition, who say his tactics are bordering on intimidation." (Rutland Herald,10/5/06)